Two autumn moods. One limited-time collection. From September 19 – October 24, Thrifted Shelf™ invites you to choose your side: spine-tingling gothic chills or warm, witchy comforts.

Inspired by beloved BookTok and Goodreads favorites, the Creepy vs. Cozy Collection features six competing scents — each one crafted to capture the magic of your reading life. Will you wander haunted halls with Nellie from The Haunting of Hill House or curl up by The Hearth with sisters Sally and Gillian of Practical Magic?

Whether you’re Team Creepy 👻 or Team Cozy 🍂, this drop won’t last long. Stock up, swap with friends, and discover your next favorite scent before the collection disappears at midnight on October 24.